- The HR Takeaways
- Posts
- Why Performance Reviews Still Feels Pointless
Why Performance Reviews Still Feels Pointless
Inside: đŻ âSomedayâ Talent Is Your Secret Weapon
Hello HR Pros,
The workplace is shiftingâfast. From AI copilots to culture-driven performance, todayâs talent landscape isnât just evolving, itâs being redefined. In this issue, we unpack the tools, trends, and truths shaping the future of HR. Whether itâs Microsoftâs vision of âagent bossesâ or Bill Gatesâ AI survival guide, one thingâs clear: strategic HR leaders are no longer just managing peopleâtheyâre orchestrating systems of humans and machines.
Letâs dive in and decode whatâs next.
đ° Upcoming in This Issue
đ€ The Rise of the Agent Boss
đ Why Your Performance Review Still Feels Pointless
đ€ The 3 Jobs AI Still Canât Take
đŻ âSomedayâ Talent Is Your Secret Weapon
đŁ Trending HR News
Tech layoffs continues: Google, Microsoft, Meta and others slash jobs (MSN)
IRS Tax Deadline Extended in 9 States: Here's Why (Newsweek)
Minimum wage for federal contractors cut down from $15 in 2025 (The HR Digest)
Oracle settles decade-long lawsuit over commission wages for $15.5M (Yahoo)
Microsoftâs article âAI at Work: How Human-Agent Teams Will Reshape Your Workforceâ reveals a seismic shift in how weâll workâwhere every employee becomes an âagent bossâ managing digital teammates.
AI isnât replacing humans; itâs amplifying them, unlocking scale without adding headcount.
The future of productivity? Itâs humans + agents, strategically paired to tackle work faster, smarter, and more creatively.
Key Takeaways
đ AI-matched individuals outperformed human-only teams â In a P&G study, solo workers using AI out-innovated traditional groups across product development tasks.
đ§ Agents neutralized team bias â With AI support, technical and commercial professionals created well-rounded solutions, regardless of their original expertise.
đ ïž Agent-led workflows are emerging â Some employees now manage multiple AI agents daily, including for live research, analysis, and writing detailed briefs.
đ The âhuman-agent ratioâ is the next KPI â Leaders must now optimize digital vs. human labor to avoid burnout and maximize team efficiency.
Deloitteâs article âReinventing performance management processes wonât unlock human performance. Hereâs what willâ makes one thing crystal clear: weâve been trying to fix the wrong thing.
Despite decades of tweaks and overhauls, only 2% of CHROs believe their performance systems actually work.
Worse? 72% of workers donât trust them at all.
This piece argues that no processâno matter how modernâcan singlehandedly unlock performance.
To truly elevate outcomes, organizations must embed performance into culture, tools, space, and daily human connection.
Key Takeaways
đ Only 6% of orgs use data well â Just a sliver of companies both capture performance value and build trust with employees through data.
đ§ 64% of workers say reviews are useless â The majority feel performance management is a time-wasting ritual that does nothing to boost their work.
đŁïž Only 26% of managers enable great performance â Most managers struggle to give clear, useful feedback, often spending just 13% of their time on developing people.
đ§© One bad teammate can tank a whole team â A study showed a single negative member cut team performance by 30â40%, regardless of overall skill or intelligence.
In the article âBill Gates predicts only three jobs will survive the AI takeoverâ, the tech titan doesnât sugarcoat it: the AI revolution is realâand itâs ruthless.
Bill Gates says most roles are at risk, but three jobs may be safe (for now): coders, energy experts, and biologists.
Each thrives on complexity, creativity, and critical thinkingâskills AI still fumbles with.
But even Gates admits the clock is ticking. The decade ahead could bring AI so advanced, it wonât just assist usâit might outthink us.
His message? If youâre not in one of these three fields, nowâs the time to adapt.
Key Takeaways
đ» Coders remain essential to build AI itself â While AI can generate code, it still canât debug or architect software like experienced human programmers can.
⥠Energy experts defy automation â Humans still lead in crisis response, regulation, and strategyâtasks too dynamic and nuanced for AI.
đ§Ź Biologists rely on intuition AI lacks â From hypothesis-making to life-saving breakthroughs, biology still needs human creativity and critical insight.
đ Only 10 years before AI could out-skill us â Gates warns that by 2035, even complex jobs could be done betterâand fasterâby AI.
In his article âWhy You Should Have A âSomeday I Might Want To Work Thereâ Talent Pipeline,â Dr. John Sullivan flips the script on traditional recruiting.
He argues that your best future hires arenât job hunting right nowâbut they are quietly admiring your company.
The solution? Create a âSomeday Groupââa loyalty-style pipeline where fans of your brand get to learn, engage, and slowly trust your culture.
This isnât a fast funnel; itâs a slow burn that builds credibility, avoids âpanic sourcing,â and gives you a pre-vetted pool of high-value, passive talent.
Key Takeaways
đ Only 6% of orgs use data to boost trust â Dr. Sullivan stresses that SG messages feel authentic, bypassing legal-polished corporate speak to win genuine candidate confidence.
đŹ Recruiting trust takes timeâmonths, not days â High-value talent often needs 6+ months of relationship-building before theyâll even agree to interview.
đ§ SG members are future-focused top performers â People thinking about âsomedayâ are planners, not driftersâtheyâre exactly who you want in your talent pipeline.
đ€ Avoids âpanic sourcingâ during urgent hires â With a warm bench of interested, educated prospects, rushed, underqualified hires become a thing of the past.
The bottomline
As we stare down seismic shifts in performance, productivity, and AI integration, one truth remains: the heart of every workplace is still human. Whether youâre reimagining your talent pipeline or reengineering your org design, the leaders who win will be those who think long-term, lead with empathy, and never stop learning.
Until next time,
Stay curious. Stay human.
How was today's edition? |